Constraint Warning with System Jobs in Nomad Triggering Non-Zero Exit Codes

Avatar
Suyash Kumar
  • Updated

Overview

This article addresses a specific challenge with constraint warnings in Nomad system jobs when deploying workloads using either Podman or Docker drivers. In certain configurations, these warnings can generate non-zero exit codes, which may interfere with monitoring systems that rely on exit codes for health checks.

 

Context

Nomad supports the use of constraint blocks within job definitions, which control where specific jobs can be scheduled based on node attributes. System jobs, which are frequently used for services that should run on all eligible nodes, may encounter issues when these constraints cause allocation placement warnings. These warnings can result in non-zero exit codes during job plans or run commands, leading to potential monitoring discrepancies.

Note: This issue has been identified in Nomad version 1.4.12 and later.

 

Problem Description

When running a nomad job plan or nomad job run on a Nomad system job without modifying the job specification, users may encounter constraint-related warnings that return a non-zero exit code, even if no changes were made to the job file. This behavior can interfere with monitoring tools that interpret non-zero exit codes as operational issues.

Updating metadata within the job definition, such as the meta parameter under the service block triggers a re-evaluation of the job. This metadata, which includes user-defined values for service registration in Consul, updates in place without restarting allocations. As a result, the allocation remains unchanged, and the constraint warning persists due to the lack of an allocation restart.

 

Reproduction Steps

To reproduce this behavior, use the following example job configuration and modify the metadata to observe the constraint warning.

Sample Job Configuration

job "example-job" {
  datacenters = ["dc1"]
  type = "system"

  group "example-group" {
    task "example-task" {
      driver = "docker"

      constraint {
        attribute = "${attr.unique.hostname}"
        value = "nomad-client"
      }

      config {
        image = "nginx:latest"
      }

      service {
        name = "example-job"
        address = "${attr.unique.hostname}"

        meta {
          APP_VERSION = 1
        }
      }
    }
  }
}

Step-by-Step Reproduction

  1. Deploy the Job: Run nomad job run example-job.hcl to deploy the job. It should successfully place the allocation.

  2. Modify Metadata in meta Block: Change APP_VERSION under the meta block from 1 to 2 without altering other job components.

  3. Plan or Re-run the Job: Execute nomad job plan example-job.hcl or nomad job run example-job.hcl again. The plan will generate a constraint warning, displaying an in-place allocation update and a non-zero exit code due to the existing constraint.

Sample Output

Upon re-running the job with an updated meta value, the following output may occur:

root@nomad-server:/home/ubuntu# nomad job plan test.hcl
+/- Job: "example-job"
+/- Task Group: "example-group" (1 in-place update)
  +/- Task: "example-task" (forces in-place update)
    +/- Service {
          Address:           "${attr.unique.hostname}"
          AddressMode:       "auto"
          Cluster:           "default"
          EnableTagOverride: "false"
      +/- Meta[APP_VERSION]: "1" => "2"
          Name:              "example-job"
          Namespace:         "default"
          OnUpdate:          "require_healthy"
          PortLabel:         ""
          Provider:          "consul"
          TaskName:          "example-task"
        }

Scheduler dry-run:
- WARNING: Failed to place allocations on all nodes.
  Task Group "example-group" (failed to place 1 allocation):
    * Constraint "${attr.unique.hostname} = nomad-client": 1 nodes excluded by filter

Job Modify Index: 143
To submit the job with version verification run:

nomad job run -check-index 143 test.hcl

When running the job with the check-index flag, the job will only be run if the 
job modify index given matches the server-side version. If the index has
changed, another user has modified the job and the plan's results are
potentially invalid.
root@nomad-server:/home/ubuntu# nomad job run -check-index 143 test.hcl
==> 2024-10-28T12:45:16Z: Monitoring evaluation "c1912c9e"
    2024-10-28T12:45:16Z: Evaluation triggered by job "example-job"
    2024-10-28T12:45:17Z: Allocation "259533f1" modified: node "9aa1f9eb", group "example-group"
    2024-10-28T12:45:17Z: Evaluation status changed: "pending" -> "complete"
==> 2024-10-28T12:45:17Z: Evaluation "c1912c9e" finished with status "complete" but failed to place all allocations:
    2024-10-28T12:45:17Z: Task Group "example-group" (failed to place 1 allocation):
      * Constraint "${attr.unique.hostname} = nomad-client": 1 nodes excluded by filter

 

This output demonstrates an in-place update attempt for the allocation, where the constraint remains unfulfilled. The non-zero exit code from this warning can impact monitoring systems that depend on exit codes to evaluate job health.

 

Technical Explanation

Nomad’s in-place update mechanism for system jobs does not restart allocations if only metadata fields, such as those in the meta block, are updated. Constraint-based warnings thus persist if the allocation does not meet the specified conditions, resulting in a non-zero exit code during the planning or run stages. This is especially relevant when the allocation needs a full restart to reassess placement with the updated constraints.

 

Workaround

To temporarily resolve the constraint warning and reset the exit code, perform a full job stop and redeploy:

  1. Stop the Job: nomad job stop example-job

  2. Re-deploy the Job: nomad job run example-job.hcl

This approach ensures that the allocation is restarted and allows Nomad to re-evaluate the constraint condition, clearing any warnings and resetting the exit code.

 

Expected Resolution

Ideally, future Nomad releases may provide enhanced handling for constraint-based warnings, especially for metadata-only updates within system jobs. Monitoring teams relying on exit codes should remain aware of this limitation and consider using the workaround to ensure consistent monitoring outcomes.

 

Additional Considerations

Note on ${attr.unique.hostname} in Constraints

When defining constraints in Nomad job specifications, special attention must be paid to the use of ${attr.unique.hostname}. This variable interpolation is unique to each client node, and conflicting constraints involving this attribute can result in unplaceable jobs.

This warning about ${attr.unique.hostname} variable interpolation can be found in the official Nomad documentation under the constraint block section.

 

Additional Notes

For environments where system stability is essential, it is recommended to validate constraint conditions before updating the job definition.

 

References

Nomad Job's constraint block

Nomad's System Scheduler

 

Articles in this section

See more

Related articles